Shipping & Delivery

Handling Instructions

Our Papa’s Cheesecake Products are baked, cooled and frozen to lock in freshness. Once your Papa’s Cheesecake(s) arrive, place in the refrigerator to fully thaw and keep cool if you plan to serve in the next 24 to 28 hours.

If your Papa’s Cheesecake is for a later date, it should be kept in the original packaging and can be FROZEN for up to 3 months.

General Information

All of our Papa’s Cheesecakes are shipped frozen in specially designed packaging to safely transport our products. We ship with icepacks.

We ship Papa’s Cheesecake anywhere in the United States. Delivery is not available to P.O Boxes and some international destinations (call for available destinations and pricing). We ship Monday thru Thursday to ensure delivery on or before Friday.

Saturday delivery is available at an ADDITIONAL COST. Please call to arrange for Saturday delivery. Orders will be filled and shipped within 2-3 business days of placing the order.

This may be delayed if shipping is due to occur on a holiday observed Federal Express our shipping vendor. 

2 pm EST Daily Cut-off Time

If your order was placed after 2:00 pm EST Monday-Friday, it will not be processed until the following business day.

Shipping Over the Weekend

If you are shipping a package to a warm weather destination over a weekend, your package may be held until the following Monday to ensure minimal time in transit.

Cost of Shipping:


Number of Cheesecakes 2-day by 4PM
1 $12
2 $19
3 $27
4 $33
5 $39


Delivery Times for Businesses & Residences

Federal Express is our preferred shipping vendor. All of our shipping vendors only deliver on business days, unless Saturday delivery is specified (where available, additional charges apply). Our shipping vendors may require a signature for delivery at the discretion of the driver.

Deliveries to businesses occur between 9 am and 5 pm, and deliveries to residences occur between 9 am and 7 pm.

International Orders

To inquire about shipping to countries other than the U.S., U.K. or Canada, please call us at (718-597-3450).

*We are unable to process international credit cards.

When Will my Order Arrive?

All Orders leave our Papa’s Cheesecake facility within 24-48 hours of processing, subject to inventory availability. International orders ship on Mondays and Tuesdays only. In order to ensure the best possible product, orders cannot ship over the weekend during warm weather months. Thus, Standard shipments packages may be held until the following Monday to ensure minimal time in transit.

Will I receive an order confirmation and tracking information?

After you place your order, you will receive an email confirmation. When the Papa’s Cheesecake is shipped, you will receive order-tracking information. You can use this information to track when your package is shipped and to inquire when it arrived.